About the Connoisseurs' Guide Rating System

Connoisseurs’ Guide (40+ yrs): Honest, unbiased CA wine reviews via monthly newsletter. Blind tastings by experts. Independent, buys wines. Global readers.

How Connoisseurs' Guide Rates

Connoisseurs' Guide to California Wine uses a 100-point scale for wine evaluation, emphasizing blind tasting and detailed assessments. Here's a breakdown using the provided template:

About the Scores:

Connoisseurs' Guide to California Wine employs a 100-point scale, focusing on blind tasting and detailed evaluations of quality.

95-100 Points:

Classic/Great
Exceptional wines displaying superior character, complexity, and craftsmanship. Represents the pinnacle of their category.
90-94 Points:

Outstanding
Wines of superior character and style, exhibiting notable distinction and excellent structure. A well-crafted selection.
85-89 Points:

Very Good
Wines with special qualities, showcasing commendable quality and enjoyable characteristics.
80-84 Points:

Good
Solid, well-made wines that are enjoyable and of commendable quality.
75-79 Points:

Mediocre
Drinkable wines that may have minor flaws, lacking the distinction of higher-scoring wines.
Below 75 Points:

Not Recommended
Wines with noticeable flaws, rarely published due to quality concerns.

Connoisseurs' Guide History

Connoisseurs’ Guide, with a legacy spanning over four decades, has established itself as a definitive resource for California wine consumers. Its readership extends across all fifty states and twenty international countries, attesting to its widespread influence and credibility. The publication is revered for its unwavering commitment to honesty, transparency, and unbiased evaluations, providing readers with forthright opinions. Transitioning into the digital realm, it is rapidly becoming a prominent online voice for California wine enthusiasts, offering an array of informative features tailored to diverse aficionados.

The Guide's core offering remains its monthly newsletter, which has earned acclaim from esteemed publications like the Los Angeles Times and the San Francisco Chronicle for its accuracy, independence, and thoroughness. Connoisseurs’ Guide employs a rigorous peer-to-peer blind tasting methodology, reviewing thousands of California and West Coast wines. This approach distinguishes it from most wine reviews, which rely on single-palate tastings, and leverages the collective expertise of industry professionals, including wine writers, sommeliers, retailers, and distributors.

Connoisseurs’ Guide prioritizes impartiality by purchasing a significant portion of the wines it reviews. While accepting samples, it maintains a policy of not limiting its assessments to submitted wines. Furthermore, it steadfastly refuses to conduct tastings at wineries with visible labels, a practice it deems bias-inducing. This commitment to objectivity may result in missing some limited-production wines, but it ensures the publication's unwavering dedication to complete independence and total objectivity. Their focus is on the consumer, and delivering reliable reviews.

  • Jancis Robinson

    Jancis Robinson: Influential wine writer (JancisRobinson.com, FT). Master of Wine, author of key references (Oxford Companion, World Atlas). OBE, 6 Beard Awards.

    Learn More 
  • SavorNW

    SavorNW: Promotes Pacific NW wines online (SavorNW.com). News, reviews, events. Organizes SavorNW Wine Awards. Connects consumers & wineries via social media.

    Learn More